Market Update · November 2, 2026 · Rick Parry
Why elections move markets for days, not decades
New Zealanders vote on Saturday 7 November 2026, just days after the United States holds its midterm elections. It's natural to wonder whether your KiwiSaver or investment portfolio is about to take a hit. The short answer from decades of research: elections can make markets jumpy for a few days, but they have very little to do with long-term returns.
Markets dislike uncertainty more than any particular outcome. A study of 27 OECD countries, released through AUT, found the country-specific part of share market volatility can easily double in the week around an election.[2]
The researchers found the jolt was bigger when the result was close, when the government changed direction, or when no party could form a clear majority. In other words, it's the surprise that moves prices, not the election itself.
That effect is usually brief. Vanguard found US share market volatility was actually slightly lower in the 100 days either side of presidential elections (1984 to 2020) than its long-run average.[3]
Vanguard's research going back to 1860 found no statistical relationship between the returns of a balanced 60/40 portfolio in US election years and non-election years. Its separate analysis of returns under different combinations of president and Congress also found no statistically significant relationship.[4]
Capital Group's analysis tells a similar story. The S&P 500 fell in only two of the last 20 US election years, 2000 and 2008, and both falls were driven by asset bubbles rather than politics.[5] Since 1936, ten-year annualised returns from the start of an election year were 11.2% when a Democrat won and 10.5% when a Republican won, a gap too small to plan around.[6]
Recent New Zealand elections show the same pattern: small moves when the result matches the polls, sharper ones when it surprises.
| Election | Market reaction |
|---|---|
| 2023 | The S&P/NZX 50 fell 0.72% on the first trading day after National claimed victory |
| 2020 | The NZX 50 eased 0.4% and the kiwi dollar barely moved, as Labour's win was broadly in line with polls |
| 2017 | After 26 days of coalition talks, the kiwi fell about 2% to a five-month low when NZ First chose Labour |
| 2014 | Power company shares jumped and the NZX 50 opened 1.3% higher after National's clear win eased regulatory fears |
Sources: BusinessDesk (2023), Good Returns (2020), NBR and The Diplomat (2017), New Zealand Inc (2014).[7][8][9][11] Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future returns.
Under MMP, the biggest uncertainty often comes after election night, while coalition deals are negotiated. 2017 is the clearest example.
Elections rarely move the whole market for long, but policy can affect particular sectors and the currency. The 2014 and 2020 reactions above were concentrated in electricity companies, which are sensitive to regulation. In 2017, the currency fall reflected concern about changes to the Reserve Bank's mandate, immigration and property rules.[10]
For most investors, the practical takeaway is diversification. A portfolio spread across sectors and countries isn't hostage to a single policy decision. Diversified KiwiSaver and managed funds typically also invest offshore, where our election has little influence.
The research points to a consistent theme: the biggest election risk to your wealth is usually your own reaction. Capital Group notes that reacting to short-term election volatility can be detrimental to returns, and that waiting on the sidelines has rarely paid off.[6]
Selling before the vote means you need to be right twice: once on when to get out, and again on when to get back in.
Switching your KiwiSaver to a conservative fund or selling shares before the vote locks in any dip. Getting the exit right is only half the call; the return has to be timed too, and markets often recover before the uncertainty feels resolved.
Governments change every few years. A good financial plan is built to work whoever is in charge.
This article is general information only and is not personalised financial advice. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future returns. Please speak with a financial adviser about your own situation.
By Rick Parry, Certified Financial PlannerCM, Co-Founder of My Net Worth
References
All content is general in nature and does not constitute personalised financial advice. My Net Worth Limited (FSP 1012016) is a Financial Advice Provider licensed and regulated by the Financial Markets Authority. A copy of our disclosure statement is available on request and free of charge.